Peer Observation of Teaching in a Performance-Managed Context: Heads of Department Perspectives from Oman



Abstract Book of the 10th International Conference on Advanced Research in Education

Year: 2026

[PDF]

Peer Observation of Teaching in a Performance-Managed Context: Heads of Department Perspectives from Oman

Shweta Bisht, Yevtushenko Engelbrecht

ABSTRACT:

Peer Observation of Teaching (POT) is widely used in higher education to enhance teaching quality, reflective practice, and professional learning. However, when embedded within performance-oriented quality assurance systems, its developmental purpose may be overshadowed by requirements for accountability, documentation, and compliance. This qualitative case study explores how Heads of Department (HoDs) at a public university in Oman conceptualize the purpose and implementation of POT, its contribution to reflective teaching improvement, and its influence on collegiality and mentoring. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with HoDs from different departments and analysed thematically through a deductive–inductive approach structured around three key areas of inquiry. The findings reveal a persistent tension between the developmental aims of POT—including professional knowledge-sharing, greater consistency in teaching practices, and quality enhancement—and an audit-oriented framing reinforced by institutional documentation requirements. HoDs identified resistance to observation arising from concerns about privacy, fear of judgement, and perceived threats to professional identity. They also highlighted limited post-observation dialogue and follow-up as barriers to translating feedback into sustained changes in teaching practice. To enhance the developmental value of POT and strengthen psychological safety, participants advocated more dialogic feedback and systematic follow-up, greater use of appreciative and strengths-based approaches, and low-stakes alternatives such as collaborative roundtables for sharing effective practices. The study recommends a clearer institutional distinction between processes required for quality assurance and those that should remain confidential and developmental. Such a distinction could reposition POT as a sustainable, trust-based cycle of professional learning while maintaining institutional accountability.

Keywords: Higher Education ; Peer Observation of Teaching (POT); Professional Learning; Quality Assurance; Reflective Practice